An Orlando-born frozen-treat shop for Italian ice, soft ice cream and layered Jelati, at Lake Nona Landing since 2018

Jeremiah's Italian Ice at Lake Nona Landing on Tagore Place

By David Myers, Broker Associate · NonaOrlandoProperties.com · Last updated October 2026

Jeremiah's Italian Ice is at 9971 Tagore Place, Suite 8, in Lake Nona Landing, next to Tabla Indian Restaurant in front of Walmart. The Lake Nona shop has been open since summer 2018. Jeremiah's was founded in Winter Park in 1996, began franchising in 2019, and has more than 170 locations in 11 states. About two dozen Italian ice flavors are made fresh in-house daily, alongside soft ice cream and Jelati, which layers the two. The shop offers indoor seating, online ordering, delivery through apps, and catering.

In a Florida summer, a cup of Italian ice is not dessert so much as survival. Jeremiah's started in Winter Park in 1996 and has been cooling down Lake Nona from Lake Nona Landing since 2018.

Here is what to order, how the layered Jelati works, and how Jeremiah's compares with the other frozen-treat stops in Lake Nona.

Where is Jeremiah's in Lake Nona?

Jeremiah's is at 9971 Tagore Place, Suite 8, in Lake Nona Landing, next to Tabla Indian Restaurant in front of Walmart.

Lake Nona Landing is the Walmart, Sam's Club and Lowe's center on Narcoossee Road just south of SR 417. Jeremiah's shares its Tagore Place building with Tabla, which makes Indian food followed by Italian ice an easy evening.

What is Jelati at Jeremiah's?

Jelati is Jeremiah's signature: Italian ice layered with soft ice cream in the same cup.

You pick an ice flavor and a soft ice cream flavor, and they are layered together, so each spoonful is part icy and part creamy. Jeremiah's used to spell it "Gelati"; the brand now uses Jelati.

The menu also includes straight Italian ice, soft ice cream, Flavorites with mix-ins, Jelati cakes and a small Tadpole size for young children.

How many flavors does Jeremiah's have?

About two dozen Italian ice flavors are made fresh in-house each day, with fruit, candy and dessert-inspired choices.

Fruit flavors such as cherry and mango sit alongside sweeter choices such as cotton candy and sea salted caramel. The lineup rotates, so the case looks a little different from visit to visit.

Many fruit ices are dairy-free, but some flavors contain dairy. Check the allergen list in the shop or online before ordering.

Who owns Jeremiah's Italian Ice?

Jeremiah's is an Orlando-based brand founded in Winter Park in 1996; it began franchising in 2019 and now has more than 170 locations in 11 states.

The founder was inspired by the water ice of the Philadelphia area. The original Winter Park store on Aloma Avenue is still open, and the brand marked its 30th year in 2026.

Jeremiah's also caters, with individually packaged treats or onsite scooping, which works well for school events and parties. Check the Lake Nona location page for hours.

How does Jeremiah's compare with Lake Nona's other dessert shops?

Jeremiah's is the Italian ice and soft-serve stop; Crumbl is the cookie shop; Menchie's and Yogurt Breeze are self-serve frozen yogurt.

Crumbl is across Narcoossee Road at Narcoossee Cove. Menchie's Frozen Yogurt is at Lake Nona Village, and Yogurt Breeze is near Nona Commons. Bacio Ice Cream Shop on Narcoossee Road is the scooped ice cream option.

For something cold, fruity and lighter than ice cream, Jeremiah's is the one.

Pros, Cons and Our Take

Pros

  • About two dozen Italian ice flavors made fresh daily
  • Jelati layers ice and soft ice cream
  • Many dairy-free fruit flavors
  • Catering for parties and school events

Cons

  • Shared parking with Walmart and Sam's Club
  • Not every flavor is dairy-free, so check allergens
  • A franchise menu with nothing specific to Lake Nona
  • A quick treat stop, not a place to linger

Our Take

Jeremiah's is a summer staple. Try a Jelati the first time, then work through the ice flavors on hotter days. Pair it with dinner at Tabla next door, and keep the catering option in mind for kids' parties.

What the Neighbors Know

Residents of Laureate Park and Alora live closest to Lake Nona Landing, and Jeremiah's is an easy evening stop on the way home.

If having everyday treats and errands close by matters to you, factor it into how you compare neighborhoods. The full list is in our Lake Nona restaurant guide.

Official Sources

Buying or selling in Lake Nona? Call/Text David Myers at 407.801.3286 or use the contact form.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is Jeremiah's Italian Ice in Lake Nona?

Jeremiah's is at 9971 Tagore Place, Suite 8, Orlando, FL 32827, in Lake Nona Landing next to Tabla Indian Restaurant.

What is Jelati?

Jelati is Italian ice layered with soft ice cream. Jeremiah's previously spelled it Gelati.

Is Jeremiah's Italian ice dairy-free?

Many fruit flavors are dairy-free, but some contain dairy. Check the allergen list before ordering.

Does Jeremiah's cater?

Yes. Jeremiah's caters with individually packaged treats or onsite scooping.

When did Jeremiah's open in Lake Nona?

The Lake Nona Jeremiah's has been open since summer 2018.