Tomasino’s Pizza: New York-Style Flavor with a Neighborhood Feel in Lake Nona

An Orlando-born New York-style pizzeria with calzones, subs and baked pasta, at Eagle Creek since the start of 2021

By David Myers, Broker Associate · NonaOrlandoProperties.com · Last updated October 2026

Tomasino's Pizza is at 14009 Narcoossee Road, Suite 130, in the Eagle Creek Center retail area, in the same building as The Naked Cupcake and Smoothie King. The Lake Nona restaurant opened at the turn of 2021. Tomasino's started in Orlando in 1999 and has five Central Florida locations. The menu covers New York-style pizza in two sizes, calzones, subs, baked pastas, wings, salads and desserts, with a kids menu. It offers dine-in, outdoor seating, in-house and app delivery, and catering.

Every neighborhood needs a reliable pizza-and-wings place for Friday night, and on the south end of Lake Nona, Tomasino's fills that role. It has been at Eagle Creek since the start of 2021.

Here is what it serves and how it compares with the brewpub in Town Center and the Italian kitchen at Lake Nona Creekside.

Where is Tomasino's in Lake Nona?

Tomasino's is at 14009 Narcoossee Road, Suite 130, in the Eagle Creek Center retail area, sharing a building with The Naked Cupcake and Smoothie King.

It is not in Lake Nona Village, despite what an earlier version of this post said. The surrounding Eagle Creek Center area also holds The Naked Cupcake, CFS Coffee, Pho Haven and Don Julio.

What does Tomasino's serve?

Tomasino's serves New York-style pizza in 14-inch and 18-inch sizes, plus calzones, 10-inch subs, baked pastas, wings, salads and desserts.

Pizzas come as traditional build-your-own or gourmet specialty pies. Subs include chicken parm, meatball and cheesesteak, and the baked dishes cover chicken and eggplant parm. Garlic knots are the standard starter, and desserts include New York cheesecake, cannoli and tiramisu.

The menu changes from time to time, so check the current version before you go.

Does Tomasino's deliver?

Yes. Tomasino's delivers itself and through the major delivery apps, and offers takeout.

For much of the south end of Lake Nona, it is one of the closest pizza deliveries. There is also a kids menu with pasta, chicken tenders and cheese pizza slices.

Check Tomasino's locations page for hours.

Does Tomasino's cater?

Yes. Tomasino's caters with pans of pasta, baked dishes and salad bowls.

It is a practical choice for team lunches, school events and family gatherings. The brand runs catering through a central line for all its locations.

How does Tomasino's compare with Lake Nona's other pizza spots?

Tomasino's is the New York-style neighborhood pizzeria; Park Pizza is the Town Center brewpub; Giovanni's is the family-run Italian kitchen at Creekside.

Park Pizza & Brewing pairs wood-fired pizza with house beer. Giovanni's Pizzeria & Kitchen has a full Italian menu with wine and beer.

Tomasino's is the one for a classic pie delivered to the door on the south end.

What the Neighbors Know

Residents of Eagle Creek, Laureate Park and Isles of Lake Nona live closest to the Eagle Creek retail area, where pizza, coffee, pho and dessert are steps apart.

If having that mix close to home matters to you, factor it into how you compare neighborhoods. The full list is in our Lake Nona restaurant guide.

Official Sources

• Tomasino's Pizza — locations
• Tomasino's Pizza — menu
• Tomasino's Pizza — catering

Buying or selling in Lake Nona? Call/Text David Myers at 407.801.3286 or use the contact form.